I do know that it takes a lot to break up with a very long relationship whether you did the breaking up or not. I mean a part of your life ended, so of course you'll feel something even if the love is no longer there. You either feel relief, emptiness, sorrow, anger, shocked, and etc. Now that i think about it, I dont think Matt's tears were fake but i dont believe that she really didn't have any idea. She knew and i do believe that the reason for the break up came from her side and also that he did the breaking up.